We compared 10 pellet grills so you don’t have to.
From Small to XL, we compared the key specs, features and prices to help you find the right pellet grill for your setup.
FINDING THE RIGHT FIT CAN BE A PAIN IN THE ASS.
With different sizes, features, cooking capacities and price points, pellet grills can all start looking the same very quickly.
So we made it easier.
We compared 10 current pellet grills from four leading brands, across sizes from Small to XL, so you can see which one best suits your setup, cooking style and budget.
MEET THE CONTENDERS
GREEN MOUNTAIN GRILLS
A pellet grill specialist with a focused current range spanning portable to full size grills. GMG has built its name around smart controls, versatility and getting a lot of functionality for the money.
TRAEGER
The company that invented the original wood pellet grill in 1987 and still one of the biggest names in the category. It also has the broadest current pellet grill range of the brands we researched.
BROIL KING
Backed by a grill manufacturer dating back to 1906, Broil King brings decades of traditional BBQ experience into a smaller, heavier duty pellet grill range.
OKLAHOMA JOE’S
Building smokers since 1987, Oklahoma Joe’s has serious BBQ credentials, including hundreds of competition wins.
ENOUGH SMALL TALK
You know the names. Now let’s see how their grills stack up:
SMALL PELLET GRILLS - STILL GETS THE JOB DONE.
| Specs | GMG Trek Prime 2.0 | Traeger Ranger |
|---|---|---|
| Cooking Capacity | 274 sq in | 176 sq in |
| Max Temperature | 550°F | 450°F |
| Connectivity | WiFi Smart Control + GMG app | No WiFIRE |
| Max Wattage | 145W | 250W |
| Hopper Capacity | 10 lb | 8 lb |
| Weight | 61.5 lb | 60 lb |
| Price | NZ$999 | NZ$999 |
Winner: GMG Trek Prime 2.0
Despite the Traeger Ranger being slightly lighter, the Trek Prime 2.0 is the stronger overall portable option with more cooking space, 550°F heat, WiFi control, a larger hopper and lower maximum power draw.
MEDIUM PELLET GRILLS - A VERY RESPECTABLE SIZE.
| Specs | GMG Ledge Prime 2.0 | Traeger Woodridge | Broil King Crown Pellet 400 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cooking Capacity | 530 sq in | 860 sq in | 635 sq in |
| Max Temperature | 550°F | 500°F | 600°F |
| Connectivity | WiFi Smart Control + GMG app | WiFIRE + Traeger app | WiFi + Bluetooth + Broil King app |
| Hopper Capacity | 20 lb | 24 lb | 18 lb |
| Why it stands out | RACKT expansion + SideBURN option | EZ-Clean + P.A.L. accessories | Cast iron grids + ash cleanout |
| Price | NZ$1,799 | NZ$1,999 | NZ$1,699 |
Winner: GMG Ledge Prime 2.0
Despite the Traeger Woodridge offering more cooking space and Broil King reaching 600°F, the Ledge Prime 2.0 offers the strongest overall mix of heat, smart control, value and expandability, with RACKT, SideBURN, pizza oven and rotisserie options.
LARGE PALLET GRILLS - HOPE YOU’VE GOT ROOM.
| Specs | GMG Peak Prime 2.0 | Traeger Woodridge Pro | Broil King Regal Pellet 500 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cooking Capacity | 738 sq in | 970 sq in | 865 sq in |
| Max Temperature | 550°F | 500°F | 600°F |
| Connectivity | WiFi Smart Control + GMG app | WiFIRE + Traeger app | WiFi + Bluetooth + Broil King app |
| Hopper Capacity | 20 lb | 24 lb | 22 lb |
| Why it stands out | RACKT expansion + SideBURN option | Super Smoke + EZ-Clean | Rotisserie + cast iron grids |
| Price | NZ$2,099 | NZ$2,599 | NZ$3,199 |
Winner: Traeger Woodridge Pro
Despite the GMG Peak reaching 550°F for less and the Broil King reaching 600°F, the Woodridge Pro edges them with the largest standard cooking area, 24 lb hopper, WiFIRE, Super Smoke and EZ Clean system.
EXTRA LARGE PALLET GRILLS - YOU’RE GONNA NEED BOTH HANDS.
| Specs | Traeger Timberline XL | Oklahoma Joe's Rider DLX G2 1200 |
|---|---|---|
| Cooking Capacity | 1,320 sq in | 1,234 sq in |
| Max Temperature | 500°F pellet chamber | 650°F Sear Mode |
| Connectivity | WiFIRE + Traeger app | No WiFi/app listed |
| Hopper Capacity | 22 lb | 20 lb |
| Why it stands out | Induction cooktop + Smart Combustion | Sear Mode + Pit Control 2.0 |
| Price | NZ$7,999 | NZ$2,499 |
Winner: Traeger Timberline XL
Despite the Oklahoma Joe’s Rider DLX 1200 reaching a higher searing temperature for much less money, the Timberline XL is the more complete setup with greater cooking capacity, WiFIRE, Smart Combustion, Super Smoke, EZ Clean and an integrated induction cooktop.
SO, WHO CAME OUT ON TOP?
There’s no perfect pellet grill for everyone. The right choice comes down to how much cooking space you actually need, the way you cook, which features matter to you and what your budget.
At this point, you’ve seen who’s packing what — now it’s just a matter of deciding what you actually want to bring home.